You Can’t Always Believe What You Read

by benborden

Its said that most of the general public believe what they read. I was taking a look at The Wall Street Journal’s Real Estate portal called Real Estate Journal and noticed and article on “What Moves Mortgage Rates” written by Teri Cullen. It always gets my curiosity when I see articles like that because 50% of the time they get it wrong, although its predominately fellow peer loan officers are the ones that really get it wrong I did not think the Wall Street Journal, “The King of Finance Media” would.

I will let you read the article but basically Teri Cullen answers the question from a reader named Victor. “Victor, mortgage rates actually follow the bond market, not the Fed-funds rate. The interest rate on a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage tracks the yield on the 10-year Treasury note (at Tuesday’s close 4.383%.).”

This is just not accurate. First, the 10 year treasury is a government backed instrument and has no direct effect on the direction of mortgage rates. Second, mortgage rates follow mortgage backed securities or MBS’s which are issued by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. While sometimes interest rates and the 10 yr tsy may move in the same direction, one does not affect the other. Very often they trade in completely opposite directions. You will notice by this quote that 6.0% mortgage bonds where up 6bp’s points and the 10-Year was down 72bp’s.

This brings me to another point. When I talk to prospective borrowers one of my handouts lists “questions to ask your loan officer” and one of the questions on the sheet to ask “What are mortgage rates based on?” Its the very basic of knowledge. This is the largest transaction of your life and far too important not to be handled by a competent, quality professional that’s trained to advise you properly. If they do not answer correctly run…do not walk to a loan officer that does know the correct answer. It always amazes me when talking to borrowers how indifferent some seem at the quality of professionals advising them on such a large transaction. Its like using a stock broker giving you quotes out of yesterdays Wall Street Journal.

Bookmark It